Overview
When Presumed Innocent begins, Rusty Sabich (Jake Gyllenhaal, Road House) has devoted his career to putting away Chicago's criminals. As the chief deputy under the city's District Attorney, he's long lived and breathed his job, plus the upholding-the-law responsibility that comes with it. He knows the city's wrongdoers. He knows the system that punishes them for their misdeeds. He knows the courts and their inner workings. In other words: he knows how to do his job and, he thinks, how to make his hometown safer. Sabich is well-aware of what legally befalls those who fall afoul of society's standards, too — but what he isn't expecting, not for a second, is to be soon treated the same way.
Audiences with knowledge of both film and literary history can see what's coming. This eight-part Apple TV+ series is the latest page-to-screen show from David E Kelley — and also another program with a story that already made the leap from bookshelves to the big screen before getting the television treatment. In recent years, Kelley has ushered A Man in Full, Anatomy of a Scandal, Nine Perfect Strangers, The Undoing and Big Little Lies down the first route. He's taken The Lincoln Lawyer down the second as well. His pedigree spinning legal narratives dates back to LA Law, The Practice, Ally McBeal and Boston Legal. Now, he's adapting author Scott Turow's debut 1987 novel, which initially became a hit 1990 Harrison Ford (Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny)-starring feature.
Turning Presumed Innocent's tale into a series and the passage of more than three decades are each a gift to its complexity, strengthening and building it in the way that a prosecutor with the aid of time and the perspective that it affords might construct their approach. There's more of the former, obviously, to fill out the intricacies of a scenario where a hotshot legal eagle usually firmly on the right side of the law is now a suspected murderer — and more space to ensure that the misogyny of the 80s and 90s doesn't still shine through. When Presumed Innocent became a movie, it was in the Fatal Attraction, Disclosure and Basic Instinct era, when Michael Douglas (Franklin) kept providing the face of men supposedly victimised by assertive women. If he'd led this picture, it wouldn't have come as a surprise. But just as Fatal Attraction has been updated for the small screen, so has Presumed Innocent.
The setup: with being the main attorney under DA Raymond Horgan (Bill Camp, who also appeared in A Man in Full) already a fraught situation — aka an election year — Sabich's life is upended when his colleague Carolyn Polhemus (Renate Reinsve, 2021's Cannes Best Actress-winner for The Worst Person in the World) is found dead. The circumstances closely resemble a case that the two had previously worked on, so Rusty takes point in attempting to bring the perpetrator to justice. It seems a logical choice. Only professional envies fuel any qualms in the office. That said, what only his supportive wife Barbara (Ruth Negga, Good Grief) knows is that Rusty and Carolyn had an affair, which almost tore apart the Sabichs' marriage.
A secret like that doesn't stay quiet, especially with Horgan's adversary Nico Della Guardia (O-T Fagbenle, Loot) and Rusty's ambitious counterpart Tommy Molto (Peter Sarsgaard, Memory) looking to appease the electorate, and quickly, as they each aspire to climb to the top jobs. No one needs to commence an investigation to uncover the resentment directed like daggers from Tommy to Rusty, both before and after the latter's romance with Carolyn is exposed. Kelley has a penchant for courtroom dramas, so that's where Presumed Innocent is headed, with Rusty on trial for murder. Kelley of late also adores facades crumbling, equally revealing how pledging to live happily ever after with the one that you love isn't the same as truly knowing them. Rusty's obsession, with the fixated texts and emails to prove it, are that shattering.
The question lingers, as it's meant to: does Presumed Innocent's protagonist deserve the viewers' presumption of innocence? The legal system must impart it, although Molto and his gleeful smirk can't, won't and don't. But should those watching give him the benefit of the doubt (and there are many doubts)? Should heartbroken artist Barbara and her and Rusty's teenaged kids Jaden (debutant Chase Infiniti) and Kyle (Kingston Rumi Southwick, 9 Full Moons), for that matter, or Horgan and his wife Lorraine (The Color Purple's Elizabeth Marvel, Camp's IRL spouse) as well? Also, as the series embraces Apple TV+'s beloved murder-mystery genre (see also: The Afterparty, Bad Sisters, Black Bird and Criminal Record, for example), what other queries should Detective Alana Rodriguez (Nana Mensah, The Diplomat) be asking as she helps Rusty attempt to clear his name?
Presumed Innocent hasn't skimped on casting, to its advantage. With Gyllenhaal, who haunted in Donnie Darko and Nightcrawler in immensely different ways, the show earns not only a gripping central performance but a slippery one. Kelley doesn't ever paint his protagonist as a hero or anything as clearcut. Amid frames that do the same visually, he sees both the light and the darkness, which Gyllenhaal can jump between like flipping a switch. As both Reinsve and Negga flesh out the women caught up in Rusty's mess, and Sarsgaard eats up the screen — particularly when Rusty and Molto face off in court — Presumed Innocent poses more questions, however, about taking any one trait or behaviour as indicative of a broader picture. Lying in some instances doesn't mean lying always. Having a loved one's back isn't the start of unconditional and perpetual reassurance. Putting your career first once isn't the same as doing it forever. Bearing a grudge doesn't mean being driven by only animosity.
With murkiness and shades of grey, there's also no holding back, then — or on twists. Cliffhangers land at the end of most episodes, as tailor-made for a viewing model that began with a double drop, then doles out the rest of the episodes week by week, regardless of if that's how viewers watch. While what it will entail beyond a brand-new case hasn't been revealed, including for its stars, a second season is on the way. Alongside season one's fellow executive producer JJ Abrams (Star Wars: Episode IX — The Rise of Skywalker), Kelley will be back, though, so presuming that more comfortable lives will implode is more than reasonable.
Check out the trailer for Presumed Innocent below:
Presumed Innocent streams via Apple TV+.