Overview
When writer Herman Melville (Ben Whishaw) knocks on the door of retired sailor Thomas Nickerson (Brendan Gleeson), he's chasing a white whale. The year is 1850, and the author is writing a novel that he'd like to base on his own time at sea as well as another true tale. When Nickerson eventually agrees to share the story of the ship he worked on three decades earlier, he's fleeing the same beast. The Essex, a Nantucket whaler, had dallied with the giant sea creature — and Nickerson had refused to talk about it since.
So starts In the Heart of the Sea, Ron Howard's account of the real-life events that inspired Moby-Dick. Based on the non-fiction book that gives the film its name, the movie both searches for and tries to escape the monstrous animal in its midst. In the narrative, it tells of men charging forward and then retreating — though as anyone familiar with Melville's epic would be aware, the whale isn't the only thing they're seeking or running from. In the feature's approach, it rises and falls in its energy and bobs and sways in its style, ensuring that the to-ing and fro-ing of story comes through in the mood and visuals.
The Essex had set off in 1819 to gather barrels of oil, with melted-down whale blubber the preferred source at the time. Two men led the crew: the untested Captain George Pollard (Benjamin Walker), who received his position due to his family name, and first officer Owen Chase (Chris Hemsworth), who boasted plenty of experience but lacked a wealthy pedigree. Their clashes rocked the boat figuratively and literally, leaving the likes of young Nickerson (Tom Holland) and second mate Matthew Joy (Cillian Murphy) caught in the middle. Keen to complete the job and get away from each other as soon as possible, Pollard and Chase ventured 10,000 leagues along the equator to find a pod of sperm whales, ignoring warnings about an unfriendly mammal that had terrorised other vessels.
While In the Heart of the Sea is framed as a showdown between Pollard and Chase, their combined foe becomes that cinema cliché — the third character in their battle. Thankfully, Howard and screenwriter Charles Leavitt (Seventh Son) know that less is more, teasing the impact of the animal more than they show it. Though the film doesn't miss a chance to flaunt its use of 3D or the aesthetic jerkiness that stems from its watery setting, this isn't a creature feature. Instead, it’s seafaring fare that's littered with more than a few arresting moments, while remaining more concerned with the trouble the whale both causes and amplifies than it does with the whale itself.
With Hemsworth playing up the drama that results, it makes for a brooding clash of egos and a blustering tale of humanity versus nature. His accent may waver, but he's a solid lead, even if he's often shouting, scowling and staring out to sea. With Gleeson, he's also an anchoring presence in a film that swims between a drunken retelling, unleashing the chaos and the fury of the ocean; and showing the kind of drifting seen in other recent seafaring films like Unbroken, All is Lost and Life of Pi. A rough but most rousing journey.
