5 to 7

Overview

Sometimes, a romantic comedy tries to do something different. Sometimes, it just seems like it does. The film's concept aside, there's little about 5 to 7 that defies convention; however even as it offers up the sweetness and convenience the genre is known for, plus a whole lot of culture clash commentary and comedy thrown in too, it proves an elegant effort to watch.

Here, adherence to type doesn’t make for a bad film, just a routine one. 5 to 7 has certain charms, but you have to be willing to go along with quite a few contrived and heavy-handed elements to enjoy them — like being told, repeatedly and through montages, that there's a difference between Americans and the French.

Chief among those obvious aspects is protagonist Brian (Anton Yelchin), aka the US-oriented party of the central couple. He's a 24-year-old aspiring writer who has dedicated his youthful years to his dream, preferring words to real-life experiences. If he sounds familiar, that's because he's the kind of earnest fellow many a movie is littered with. And those of his ilk often find their world changed through a chance meeting with a lovely lady, such as as the one that starts Brian's connection with European export Arielle (Bérénice Marlohe).

After spotting her on the streets of New York City, Brian and Arielle chat and agree to cross paths again the next week. Their catch-ups then move to the titular hours of 5pm to 7pm, which is when she says she is available. The reason for her limited schedule: she’s married with two kids. While her diplomat husband (Lambert Wilson) is fine with her having an affair — in fact, he's having one as well, with an up-and-coming literary editor (Olivia Thirlby) — confining their extramarital dalliances to that daily period is just the way the French apparently do things.

Cue Brian's intertwined infatuation and anguish, playing out over typical rom-com park strolls, hotel room liaisons and long chats about everyone's feelings. His parents (Glenn Close and Frank Langella) share reservations about their arrangement, but are similarly won over by Arielle — which shows just how lightly 5 to 7 skims the surface of its scenario. This isn't a film about challenging traditional ideas about relationships, or even exploring something different; it's simply a standard romance narrative navigating a series of problems, using adultery as a point of difference and wrapping everything up in "but she's French!" sentiments.

Somehow, though, the actors and their subtle performances mostly make the movie work. Yelchin isn't helped by the writer-side of his character (with a wannabe author looking for his big break also frequent film fare), yet his awkwardness comes across as genuinely as his rapport with Marlohe. When they're just walking and talking, Woody Allen and Richard Linklater style, they're at their best, even if their dialogue remains a collection of clichés and clunky lines.

That first-time feature writer/director Victor Levin likes to largely look on from afar, gives the film a leisurely pace, and knows how to put a graceful image together also helps the handsomely shot offering, which clearly aims to be one of cinema's classic love stories. Of course, 5 to 7 never reaches such heights, but it is a breezy and pleasing-enough attempt beneath the platitudes and predictability.