In partnership with
Overview
The stage play Doubt: A Parable first premiered at New York's Manhattan Theatre Club in 2004. In a post-9/11 America reckoning with questions of authority, accountability and who gets believed, US playwright John Patrick Shanley used the intimate setting of a Catholic school to explore moral uncertainty and the tension between conviction and proof.
Two decades on, the Pulitzer Prize-winning drama is returning to Sydney — and it feels more urgent than ever. Running from Tuesday, June 30 to Sunday, August 2 at the Roslyn Packer Theatre, this new production of Doubt: A Parable invites audiences to sit with ambiguity, question their assumptions and leave the theatre with more questions than answers.
Starring Pamela Rabe as Sister Aloysius and marking Sam Reid's Sydney Theatre Company debut, the production places two of Australia's most compelling performers opposite one another in one of the most celebrated plays of the twenty-first century. And according to Pamela, that post-show conversation is part of the point. She hopes audiences leave not only having experienced a great night at the theatre, but carrying the debate with them long after they step outside.
"The era when it was written, the phrase, 'If you're not with us, you're against us,' was starting to gain real currency," says Pamela. "We certainly moved on from there into a kind of cancel culture and trial by social media. The play raises the question: how do we continue to listen to each other? How do we sit in a place of certainty, uncertainty? That feels even more important today than at the time it was written."
Set in 1964 in the Bronx, Sister Aloysius (Rabe), the formidable headmistress of St Nicholas Church School, begins to suspect charismatic priest Father Flynn (Reid) of inappropriate behaviour involving the school's only Black student, Donald Muller. Father Flynn denies the allegations completely.
Directed by Marion Potts in her return to Sydney Theatre Company, the production also stars Zindzi Okenyo and Shannen Alyce Quan, bringing together what Pamela describes as an extraordinary creative team. Speaking with Concrete Playground toward the end of rehearsals, I ask how such an American story will translate to Australian audiences. Her answer is immediate.
"It's not really an American story," Pamela says. "It's a global story." The actress compares the time the play is set in to our modern era.
Pamela points to the world John Patrick Shanley built: 1964 America, in the shadow of John F. Kennedy's assassination, with Cold War anxieties and sweeping change within the Catholic Church underway, but says those details simply become a lens through which bigger human questions emerge.
"It was a very anxious time. [John Patrick Shanley] is using that as a crucible for a conversation which speaks to all of us. Goodness knows we're sitting in a very anxious time right now."
From the 1960s to the early 2000s, and now, with a 2026 production at Roslyn Packer Theatre, Doubt: A Parable is a story that transcends eras. One that continues to endure, and one that audiences keep returning to decades later.
"It was sort of an instant classic, but it also feels like a masterpiece now," says Pamela. "If the definition of a classic is that it can go through many eras and many versions of what we consider to be the truth of the day and still hold up and make you see it through a prism of different conversation, different thoughts, different events, different ideas, then that to me is a classic."
As we sit in an anxiety-inducing time, Pamela hopes that by people heading to the theatre to experience the story and "grapple with ideas as a community", the story won't end at curtain call. It will follow you onto the ferry, into dinner afterwards and all the way home.
Don't miss Doubt: A Parable at Roslyn Packer Theatre this season. Book your tickets now.
Image Credit: Supplied