The Playmaker
Let's play
  • It's Tuesday
    What day is it?
  • Now
    What time is it?
  • Anywhere in Sydney
    Where are you?
  • What do you feel like?
    What do you feel like?
  • And what else?
    And what else?

The Best Places to Buy Next-Level Cheese in Sydney

These shops see your cheese dreams and sell all the smelly slices — along with toasties, coffee and wine — to make them come true.
By Georgia Hough and Concrete Playground
May 04, 2020

The Best Places to Buy Next-Level Cheese in Sydney

These shops see your cheese dreams and sell all the smelly slices — along with toasties, coffee and wine — to make them come true.


These shops see your cheese dreams and sell all the smelly slices — along with toasties, coffee and wine — to make them come true.

These days, there are plenty of places to find cheesy dishes and elaborate cheese boards — but there's nothing quite like purchasing a few quality wedges of hand-picked fromage, freshly sliced charcuterie and a matching bottle of wine to take away and dig into. Home to some of the largest cheese selections in the country, Sydney's cheese shops are defined by honest, passionate owners, an appreciation for Australian-made products and exceptional cheese options. From long-running historic operations in the CBD to small artisan cheese shops in Manly, we've put together a list of the best shops to pick up a slice or two — whether you're just after your go-to favourite or something fancy and new. 

If you choose to pick up your cheese rather than have it delivered, have a look at the latest COVID-19 advice and social-distancing guidelines from the Department of Health.

  • 7

    Walk into Penny’s Cheese Shop, and you’d think you’d died and gone to cheese heaven. With two fridges stocked to the brim with creamy, stinky, funky and hard cheeses this little unassuming fromagerie is one of the best in Sydney. Why, you ask? Because of Penny. Whatever you’re looking for — or even if you’re not looking for anything at all — you’ll leave with a cheese that is your new favourite. Almost everything, like nearby Whole Beast Butchery, is cut to order. Little tasters are on offer most days, too, which should make it even easier to find a cheese you like. With an emphasis on education and service, Lawson, a self-professed “curd-nerd”, will guide you through her selection of local and international cheeses with humour and excitement. Aside from the service and the cheese, Lawson’s golden toasties, which quickly achieved cult status, are another reason you’ll return to the shop again and again and again. With cheese both on the inside and the outside of the Pioik bread, as well as a rotating range of fillings — from kimchi to smoked wagyu and jalapeños — we think they might just be the best in the city.

    Penny’s Cheese Shop is open for takeaway only.

    Images: Kimberley Low.

  • 6

    Bad smells usually have you heading in the opposite direction. But The Stinking Bishops is the exception. The Newtown boutique cheese bar and shop proves that cheese is one of few foods where an overwhelmingly onerous stench is considered a virtue. The wall of glory behind the counter invites visitors to gawk at the variety of Australian and imported cheeses and cured meats available. A large blackboard to the side outlines them in more detail — and for even more information and suggestions, the delightful team on board will offer their sage advice. As well as straight cheese, this bar also has cheesy meals, such as guanciale mac ‘n’ cheese and a five-cheese toastie.

    The Stinking Bishop is currently open for takeaway from Wednesday–Sunday and is offering delivery via DoorDash.

  • 5

    Sitting on the corner of Wentworth Street and East Esplanade, just steps from Manly’s Ferry Wharf, is the Artisan Cheese Room. Occupying a small corner shop, this delightful room is created for cheesemongers, by cheesemongers. Owners Joanna and Paul Thompson opened up the carefully curated cheese haven after successful careers elsewhere — although a career in cheese with your significant other feels like a whole different level of success. Inside you can browse over 50 cheeses sourced from across the world, as well as from just a few hours’ drive away. If you’re now hankering for a cheese plate, then you might be interested in the store’s Cheese Club which provides a selection of cheeses each month along with biscuits and tasting notes (for all you cheese newcomers out there). Cheese lovers can choose between four options — or one ($90), three ($260), six ($530) or 12 months ($1000) of cheese.

    The Artisan Cheese Room is open for takeaway and delivery. Free same-day delivery is available for Manly and surrounding suburbs, with Sydney metro same-day delivery on offer for a fee.

  • 4
    Formaggi Ocello

    The meat and cheese cases at Ocello’s corner shop are nothing short of impressive. Stacks of a brie, gorgonzola and pecorino sit next to hunks of exotic stiltons from the English countryside to complex milk cheeses from Italy. Ocello also has very knowledgeable staff who encourage the customer to try before they buy — particularly helpful (and necessary) when the cheese selection is one of the largest in Australia. Opposite Ocello’s main attraction are walls filled with complementary gourmet products like handmade pasta, olive oil, biscuits, nuts, wine, spreads… you get the idea. You can also pop in for lunch and a coffee or an afternoon glass of wine. We recommend ordering the four-cheese panini — and asking them to add truffle butter.

    Formaggi Ocello is open for takeaway and delivery, which is free for Surry Hills and surrounding suburbs. The rest of Australia can order delivery for a $29.50 flat rate.

  • 3
    Field Blend Wine & Cheese Store

    There’s nothing complicated or flashy about this wine and cheese shop. Sleek and thoughtfully presented, Field Blend provides a wide range of Australian and international wine choices with matching meats and cheeses for reasonable prices. Owners Martina Brazdovicova and Aaron Taylor have brought expertise from their previous wine shop in in the country town of Beechworth, Victoria to Balmain’s Darling Street. A visit to the quaint neighbourhood shop isn’t just transactional, either — in a nice touch, you’ll find a La Marzocco coffee machine so you can grab a coffee while you peruse your wine and cheese choices for later. A Berkel slicer cute your meat for you while you wait, too. The entrepreneurial duo has also launched its own wine club, which sends subscribers two bottles — ones that are well-circulated and good value, or exciting new finds from international and domestic wineries. Field Blend sources its wine and cheese from everywhere from France to small operations in rural Australia, so there’s no pretension here — just good stuff.

    Field Blend Wine is open for takeaway only.

  • 2
    Paesanella Food Emporium

    Sitting three storeys above its pizza restaurant, Paesenella’s Food Emporium in Marrickville is a modern delight with a deep history. Italian Immigrant Umberto Somma arrived in Australia in 1956 and made a living selling his handmade mozzarella to the working class. More than half a century later and his legacy is encapsulated in the Paesenella brand, which sells their own buffalo mozzarella and ricotta made in its nearby factory. The Food Emporium has cookbooks, pasta, and imported goods, but the real treasures lie behind the gleaning glass cases that hold the freshly made Paesenella cheese packaged and ready to take home.If you’re looking for something heartier than a ball of mozzarella, the restaurant and pizza bar dishes out gourmet pizza pies made exclusively with Paesenella cheeses.

    Paesenella Food Emporium is open for takeaway. You can order its pizza for delivery via UberEats.

  • 1
    Fourth Village Providore

    Few shops can claim to be a true family affair, but Fourth Village is one of them — and it’s a quality that only enriches the character of this lower north shore providore. The Quattroville family has curated an impressive supply of high-calibre products, with a deli, cheese room, flower shop and grocer all in the one place. The cheese room is where it’s at. All cheeses (from a raw milk roquefort to the Holy Goat cheese from Sutton Grange Organic Farm in Victoria) are cut to order and you can ask to try a taste before you buy. Fourth Village also has a restaurant selling pizza, pasta, risotto and salad — all made with plenty of cheese, of course.

    Fourth Village is open for takeaway and is offering a valet pick up service for both its deli and restaurant.


Top image: Penny’s Cheese Shop by Kimberley Low. 

  •   shares
Tap and select Add to Home Screen to access Concrete Playground easily next time. x