Overview
Australia's Wine List of the Year Awards has celebrated its 32nd anniversary in a prestigious award ceremony at NSW Parliament House, where 300 of the industry's top players came together to see who would take out top spot this year. It will come as no surprise to any lucky wine lovers who have visited Melbourne newcomer Circl to learn that the wine house on Punch Lane took out the prized trophy for Australia's Best Wine List for 2025.
The venue, which has fostered a new culture of accessibility and inclusivity when it comes to trying rare wines, offers more than 150 drops by the glass and approximately 1,500 wines by the bottle. And while there were a few other notable winners this year, Circl dominated the awards across multiple categories for good reason. They picked up the awards for Best List of Wines by the Glass, Best Champagne List, Best Sparkling Wine List, Best Wine List Victoria, Best Wine List — City, and Best Listing of Victorian Wines.
We can only imagine what exquisite champagne Xavier Vigier, Circl's sommelier, chose to pop to celebrate such an impressive collection of awards. And Vigier himself also took out top prize, winning the Sommelier's Choice Award, which is voted upon by Australian sommeliers, as well as the coveted Judy Hirst Award, which recognises the sommelier responsible for curating the winning list.
Senior Judge Andrew Graham praised Circl's wine list for its accessibility and its expansiveness. Graham says, "So often, the great wines of the world seem almost mythical. They're things that drinkers dream about, but so rarely get to experience. Yet the astonishing list from Circl resets what is accessible. Led by a truly sublime offering of wines by the glass, which is gleefully heavy with famous 'unicorns', there is eye-watering depth throughout this list. You can start with the wonderfully well contextualised champagne offering, take a flight of rare rosé and end up with a dive into magnificent rare old Australian shiraz. What a journey!"
Bennelong won the Best Wine List NSW, Fico took out the title in Tasmania, and Agnes in Queensland. Six venues were added to Australia's Wine List of the Year Hall of Fame, including Melbourne Supper Club, Stillwater in Hobart, and The Boat House in Canberra. Chris Lucas' Maison Bâtard was awarded the Tony Hitchin award for Australia's Best New Wine List, and Society succeeded with the Best Digestif List, Australia's Best Listing of Museum and Rare Wines, and Australia's Best Listing of French Wines.
Rob Hirst OAM, who founded the awards with his late wife Judy in 1993, says, "We're grateful to receive such significant support from the industry and our award partners for yet another year of Australia's Wine List of the Year Awards, and the quality of wine lists across the country has never been better. There is a clear interest and intent by sommeliers, venue owners and beverage managers and directors to build harmony and synergy between the menu and drinks list, and this year's results are proof that the skill and dedication to this task is stronger than ever."
Circl's extraordinary accomplishment makes it a back-to-back win for Victorian venues, with the award going to Gimlet at Cavendish House in 2024. The prestige and importance of the awards were summarised by the Chairman of Judges, Peter Forrestal. "The enthusiasm with which those involved in restaurants and, more generally, in serving the public is infectious. The imaginative quality of the food being brought to Australian restaurant tables and the wines that sommeliers have to offer their customers has never been more satisfying or stimulating. The education of sommeliers is at an all-time high. Documenting all this since 1994 is Australia's Wine List of the Year with another record number of entries to affirm the quality of individual restaurants and to record excellence at the table."
Images: supplied, feature image, Arianna Leggiero.
Has all this talk of wine made you thirsty? Check out the best wine bars in Melbourne today.